Your Local One‑Stop Insurance Agency

Welcome to Rodgers & Co Insurance

Your Local One‑Stop Insurance Agency

At Rodgers & Co Insurance, we help individuals, families, and small businesses across Northwestern Pennsylvania and Northeastern Ohio communities compare coverage, cut costs, and feel confident in what they’re paying for. Whether you’re insuring your car, your home, or your livelihood—we’ve got you covered, all in one place.

Coverage That Works as Hard as You Do

We make it easy to find insurance that fits your life, not the other way around. As a local, family-owned insurance agency, we help you compare rates and options from top companies to find the right fit without the runaround.

Here’s what we can help you with:

Black car icon viewed from the front

Auto Insurance

Protect your ride, your wallet, and your liability with flexible coverage options across PA and OH.

Black house icon with a white door on a white background

Home Insurance

From storm damage to liability, we’ll help you protect your biggest investment.

Black briefcase with a shield emblem and shoulder straps icon

Commercial Insurance

We work with small business owners to craft policies that actually make sense for their industry.

Black building icon with white windows and a central door

Renters, Condo & Flood Insurance

For wherever and however you live, we’ll help keep what matters protected.

Black motorcycle with sidecar icon on white background

Motorcycle, Boat & RV Insurance

Seasonal or year-round coverage tailored to your toys.

Hands holding a black heart with a white heartbeat line symbol

Life & Health Insurance

Because protecting your people is just as important as protecting your things.

Want to explore personal and commercial insurance? View all services››

Why So Many Neighbors Refer Rodgers & Co

There’s a reason most of our business comes from referrals. We’ve been serving Mercer County, PA and nearby Ohio towns like Hubbard, Girard, and Youngstown for over two decades. Our agency was built from the ground up in 2001, and today we continue to offer the kind of honest, small-town service that’s getting harder to find.



Here’s why clients stick with us:

Shield with checkmark inside circular arrows, black and white security icon

28+ years of insurance experience

Hand holding a shield with a checkmark and a dollar coin icon, symbolizing secure payments

We’re truly independent—not tied to one company

Black shield with white checkmark inside square brackets icon

One-stop shopping for nearly every kind of coverage

Black group icon with a shield and check mark, suggesting user protection or security.

Real people you can call, email, or visit in person

Hand holding rising bar chart with upward arrow and dollar symbol icon

We focus on increasing protection while keeping costs in check

Proudly Serving the Pennsylvania–Ohio Border Region

From Sharon and Hermitage to New Castle, and just across the line in towns like Poland, Boardman, and Austintown—we serve individuals, families, and business owners across Mercer and Lawrence Counties in PA and Trumbull and Mahoning Counties in OH.


Whether you’re commuting down I-80, running a small business near the Shenango River, or living lakeside near Pymatuning, we understand the risks and requirements unique to our area.

We Work With Insurance Companies You Know & Trust

Our independent status means we’re not stuck with one provider. Instead, we work with a range of highly rated insurance carriers—including:


  • Auto-Owners Insurance
  • Progressive
  • Westfield
  • Millville Mutual
  • Safeco
  • Grange
  • Agents Insurance Company
  • And others for commercial policies

Need to file a claim or pay a bill?

We’re Here to Help!

Whether you’re shopping for your first policy or reviewing what you’ve had for years, our team is here to help—without the pressure. Give us a call, stop by the office in West Middlesex, or use our easy online tool to compare quotes in minutes.